Talking Nutrition
Talking Nutrition is the podcast for women who did everything right and stopped seeing results. Hosted by Johan Vesters, online nutrition and functional health coach, and founder of Odyssey Coaching Systems, the show digs into what is actually going on under the surface: metabolism, fat loss, thyroid, hormones, gut health, blood work, and the mindset and behavior change that makes results stick. No crash diets, no quick fixes, no fear-mongering. Just education, real client stories, and honest conversations, so you can understand your own body, ask better questions, and take ownership of your health.
Follow @johanvesters_ocs on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/johanvesters_ocs/
For coaching applications: https://odysseycoachingsystems.co/coaching-application
Talking Nutrition
4 - CrossFit Performance, Cutting, & Muscle Maintenance
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Q: "Smart ways to maintain muscle mass and performance while cutting?".
In this episode you'll learn about smart ways to maintain muscle mass and performance while cutting. We talk about periodization, training, nutrition, and give a general recommendation for the person who asked us about this topic.
For context: she's a CrossFit enthusiast who trains a lot, is already quite lean, and would like to lose a little bit of body fat while maintaining her muscle, strength, and performance.
- - -
In this episode:
https://www.vestersnutrition.com/maintain-muscle-while-cutting/
Talking Nutrition is brought to you by Odyssey Coaching Systems.
- Website and free resources: https://odysseycoachingsystems.co/
- Follow Johan on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/johanvesters_ocs/
- Apply for coaching: https://odysseycoachingsystems.co/coaching-application
0:30
welcome back to talking nutrition
0:33
we are going to touch on smart ways to
0:36
maintain muscle mass and performance
0:38
while
0:39
cutting today and johan is going to talk
0:43
a little bit about context before we
0:45
jump into things
0:47
awesome thank you i think it's very
0:49
important right because
0:50
on this podcast to the listener like we
0:53
can't coach you
0:55
on a podcast right we don't know
0:57
anything really about your lifestyle
0:59
nutrition goals training
1:02
weight height etc all that stuff
1:05
so i want to emphasize the importance of
1:07
context and this question we got
1:10
actually in our q a box but i figured
1:12
let's do a full episode on it
1:15
just because it's something we can
1:16
really dive a little bit deeper into and
1:18
really break down
1:20
so i do want to
1:21
explain a little bit more um who's
1:23
asking this question right
1:25
so basically they asked me
1:27
hey how can i maintain as much muscle as
1:29
possible
1:30
and
1:31
keep my performance up
1:33
while cutting so to give you a little
1:35
bit of context so this person
1:37
is very much in the crossfit she's very
1:39
active
1:40
at the gym she's also a crossfit coach
1:42
she works out a lot uh but she wants to
1:44
lose a little bit of weight to help with
1:46
like the body weight movements etc
1:49
now she also wants to
1:50
keep her strength up right hold on to
1:52
muscle because then she doesn't want to
1:54
suffer in terms of weight lifting
1:57
so this is someone who's already i'd say
1:59
quite lean she wants to lose a little
2:02
bit of weight so this is going to be
2:03
much different compared to someone who
2:06
wants to lose let's say 10 kilos so just
2:08
wanted to emphasize that this person is
2:10
already very much into training and what
2:13
it's going to be for you will really
2:14
depend on your fitness level your you
2:17
know how much muscle you have a body fat
2:19
percentage etc
2:21
and to be honest too like not a lot of
2:24
people that we work with really go to
2:26
super low body fat percentages which is
2:28
when it actually gets more risky so the
2:31
lower fat percentage we get
2:33
the higher the risk of muscle loss will
2:35
be
2:36
right exactly
2:38
um
2:40
the issue
2:41
with
2:43
performance and fat loss is that they
2:46
don't go hand in hand
2:48
right like you're
2:50
focusing on
2:52
performance we shouldn't
2:54
necessarily be too worried about body
2:57
fat percentage like
2:59
i guess there's a a point there where
3:01
like
3:02
there could be
3:05
crossfit athletes that want to lose a
3:07
little bit of body fat percentage to
3:09
improve their gymnastics but then you
3:11
have to be careful because then you run
3:13
the risk of losing strength right and
3:16
this is something i'm always talking
3:18
to about
3:20
um talking with about what oh my gosh
3:22
talking to my clients about who are
3:26
more on the performance side of things
3:29
so the issue when it comes to
3:31
performance and fat loss is that they
3:34
require
3:36
the opposite so performance typically
3:39
requires you to
3:40
be eating
3:42
a lot of food at maintenance or in a
3:44
surplus and a fat loss phase is going to
3:46
require you to be in a calorie deficit
3:50
and a calorie deficit can impact
3:54
performance negatively
3:56
so
3:57
the approach becomes really important
4:00
here
4:01
and when we're talking about
4:04
an athlete going into a calorie deficit
4:08
we have to understand that we might run
4:11
into performance dips for a period of
4:14
time or we might have to
4:17
lower
4:18
training volume because of the stress
4:20
because we're trying to manage stress
4:22
right
4:22
so
4:24
let's dive a little bit deeper into what
4:27
that process might look like for
4:30
someone who's performance based but
4:33
wants to lose a little bit of body fat
4:35
so it's also really about getting into
4:37
this with the right expectations right
4:40
knowing okay cool what you just
4:41
mentioned i will lose a little bit of my
4:44
performance
4:45
i'll get it back but right now in the
4:47
short term
4:48
that's actually not going to be
4:50
the the main focus or the priority right
4:52
now in this case it's fat loss i was
4:55
going to say weight loss fat loss
4:58
so being aware of that and this also
5:00
means that you need to align this with
5:02
your season right i was just going to
5:05
talk on that
5:08
because if you have competitions coming
5:10
up or maybe whether that's a local
5:12
competition or even like a higher level
5:14
competition
5:16
you probably don't want to be in a
5:17
deficit when you're on the floor you
5:19
know
5:19
and this also goes for the open or here
5:22
in norway we have like a functional
5:24
fitness
5:25
competition which is getting pretty big
5:27
now actually
5:28
naturally
5:30
and same thing
5:31
last year i forgot how it was this year
5:34
they had it back to back
5:36
so they had to cross it open right into
5:38
the other one or what's the other way
5:39
around anyway it doesn't matter
5:41
so it was like two back to back where
5:44
you know you can imagine if both are
5:45
like four weeks long that's pretty
5:47
taxing
5:49
that's basically
5:50
two months of going hard
5:53
that's why you want to fuel
5:55
eat a whole lot sleep a whole lot and
5:57
you want to be at your best
6:00
calorie deficit doesn't allow you to be
6:01
at your best
6:03
a lot of stress on this system
6:06
with crossfit and
6:08
less food
6:10
being in a catabolic state it's it's
6:12
risky business in my opinion yeah yeah
6:15
well you're speaking from experience
6:18
sure i am
6:20
but just make sure what i'm trying to
6:22
say is like don't diet when you're
6:24
expecting to
6:26
get a pr
6:27
or you're testing for whatever or it's
6:29
to open or any other sport really it
6:30
doesn't have to be crossfit specific
6:33
so make sure to plan your year because
6:35
that trade-off is one that you're going
6:37
to have to make
6:38
at least if you first want to
6:39
effectively lose body fat and then
6:42
switch back to the performance again
6:43
because
6:44
you will lose a little bit of
6:46
performance
6:47
but you'll get it back
6:49
yep
6:50
um
6:53
the the next thing i want to touch on is
6:57
um
6:59
so the approach essentially
7:03
with someone who's performance based we
7:06
kind of want to
7:08
get in and get it we don't want to be
7:10
hanging around in a deficit for a long
7:12
period of time
7:13
so again this is why context is so
7:15
important because this approach might be
7:18
different for someone who isn't
7:19
performance based right
7:22
so
7:23
someone who's in crossfit me and johann
7:25
both agree that we would take a more of
7:28
an aggressive approach
7:31
it's a shorter time period we're
7:34
dropping calories quicker
7:37
that way the stress
7:40
we're not stressing the system for a
7:42
long period of time
7:45
right so that might look like
7:48
15 20 25
7:50
deficit right off the top you know
7:53
staying in
7:55
that cup for like
7:57
how long six to eight weeks maybe like
8:00
around there i would say maybe eight
8:02
weeks i mean that's still a short period
8:04
of time
8:05
um but again you're managing that
8:08
overall stress that way we're not
8:10
stressing the system for too too long
8:12
i totally agree because the longer we
8:14
diet the the worse we're going to be off
8:16
in terms of
8:18
adaptations
8:19
performance or loss of performance as
8:21
you'd say
8:22
and and risking you know losing muscle
8:25
mass so all together it's kind of like
8:27
let's just get it done you know let's
8:29
get it over with let's maybe not go too
8:32
aggressive remember that the rates that
8:33
we talked about earlier
8:36
in another episode
8:37
uh where it's like maybe the one percent
8:39
okay cool let's maybe not go beyond that
8:42
and depending on the person we might
8:43
look into that rate or not but
8:45
let's go hard let's get in get out
8:48
just to make sure
8:50
that we don't give the metabolism too
8:52
much time to slow down right
8:55
now additionally
8:57
it's all time that you're not spending
9:00
building muscle
9:03
so the longer in a deficit
9:05
the less time you're spending
9:07
eating enough
9:09
actually facilitating muscle growth or
9:10
at least you know maintaining what you
9:12
have
9:13
and so also you know being able to
9:15
really chase performance again
9:17
so that's why i totally agree i think we
9:20
should get out
9:21
basically as soon as possible right
9:23
without
9:25
going too aggressive so you see there's
9:27
a fine line here i know
9:29
i'll try having a coach is so helpful
9:33
we're biased but it's true yeah
9:37
um
9:38
the next thing is to
9:40
keep protein high i mean this goes
9:44
for everyone across the board to be
9:46
honest with you
9:47
um
9:49
it's going to help simply maintain that
9:51
muscle it's going to give you the
9:52
materials to
9:54
do so protein literally
9:56
plays into
9:58
every cell and tissue in our body and so
10:00
we need to be getting an adequate amount
10:03
um with
10:06
athletes or performance based
10:09
individuals i typically recommend like 1
10:11
gram
10:12
or 1 to 1.2 1.4 grams per pound of body
10:16
weight
10:17
um
10:18
again
10:19
someone who is leaner is going to need a
10:22
little bit more i'd say a lot more than
10:25
someone who has
10:27
more body fat to lose so we want to keep
10:30
that protein high it's also going to
10:32
help with satiety and fullness right
10:35
managing that hunger
10:36
and keeping protein high as you said is
10:38
not even just important in a cut we
10:41
actually want to
10:42
bring it up a little but other than that
10:44
we don't necessarily want to mess with
10:46
it too much anyway compared to
10:47
maintaining or bulking right it's
10:50
it's going to always be
10:52
the priority in terms of macros and then
10:55
unfortunately
10:56
where we're going to have to make the
10:57
adjustments are going to be your carbs
10:59
and your fats
11:01
now knowing that this person once again
11:03
contacts so this person is doing a lot
11:05
of crossfit a lot of training a lot of
11:07
stress on the body
11:09
she wants to maintain performance as
11:11
much as possible as well as maintenance
11:13
carbohydrate is going to be a priority
11:15
for her why is that carbs first of all
11:18
are your preferred fuel source
11:20
especially for that high intensity
11:22
sports like crossfit
11:24
but it's also going to play a huge role
11:26
in
11:27
shutting off cortisol like after
11:29
training
11:30
because when you eat carbs we spike
11:32
insulin which then can blunt cortisol
11:34
and kind of bring you out of that stress
11:36
state
11:37
which is also very important so you can
11:39
see that okay we got protein carbs our
11:42
priority and then what's left are fats
11:46
now you don't want to completely take
11:47
out your fats but you can go pretty low
11:50
so i can't really give you an exact
11:51
prescription here when it comes to your
11:53
macros right but remember protein is
11:55
going to be priority and carbohydrate
11:58
for you know performance also recovery
12:00
nfs are a little bit less of a priority
12:03
but here also context matters uh we
12:05
don't necessarily know
12:07
how much this would be so so we can't
12:09
necessarily say like these should be
12:11
your macros but just be aware that carbs
12:13
are going to be a little bit more
12:15
important here compared to fats
12:17
exactly
12:19
um and then we have here like keep
12:22
lifting weights but we know that
12:23
crossfit people are going to keep
12:24
lifting weights they're going to keep
12:26
doing exactly what they're doing
12:28
um
12:29
talking a little bit about
12:31
potentially
12:36
lowering volume a little bit um just
12:39
based on how you feel i mean that can
12:41
help again we have to remember it's
12:43
temporary
12:44
um
12:45
and we can increase volume intensity
12:47
again once we're out of the deficit but
12:49
we're trying to manage some of that
12:51
stress so
12:53
that can be based on how you're feeling
12:56
for sure
12:57
some people respond better you know to
12:59
deficits and stress others don't so
13:01
again that's going to be
13:03
very individualized
13:05
on
13:06
the training side of things
13:09
and like for me
13:11
um i actually never dieted when i was in
13:14
crossfit never on purpose
13:17
uh i under ate
13:20
just because i didn't have the knowledge
13:22
um but once i had a nutrition coach who
13:26
was feeding me
13:27
and i had a uh my actual crossfit coach
13:32
those two were interacting so if this is
13:35
you that's really important to make sure
13:38
that like
13:39
your nutrition coach and your actual
13:42
coach
13:43
know what's happening
13:44
um
13:45
so they can adjust if needed right even
13:48
if like you potentially need a refeed
13:51
day or like something like that but it's
13:53
really important for you to
13:55
be communicating and not trying to just
13:58
be tough and push through feeling like
14:00
like it's you just you don't want
14:03
to do that so
14:05
if you're in the cut and you're feeling
14:07
like
14:08
super fatigued you know you're really
14:10
seeing performance hit make sure that
14:13
you're communicating that with your
14:14
nutrition coach also your regular coach
14:18
and potentially they'll add something in
14:19
like a refeed which can help for the
14:22
time being you know um this is kind of
14:25
going off of what we had planned but i'm
14:28
thinking back to my own experience
14:30
um it's just really important to
14:34
be
14:34
open
14:35
and be transparent about how you're
14:38
feeling and communicate
14:40
because it's only going to benefit you
14:42
right a lot of the time
14:45
crossfitters try to be tough
14:48
right they're they're they are tough
14:49
they are tough i should say they're not
14:51
they're not trying to be tough but
14:53
they'll push through things
14:55
right injuries feeling like crap
14:58
right so
15:00
yeah i i just want to emphasize
15:02
communication you know with your coach
15:04
if you do have one
15:06
right if you don't i mean
15:08
you can't really communicate yes
15:12
cause like this person she's a coach too
15:13
by the way and uh
15:16
so mostly on the training side of things
15:18
hey coaches need coaches too oh oh yeah
15:20
for sure that's why you have coaches why
15:22
i have a coach but we both have mentors
15:24
in
15:25
spend a lot of money
15:27
on that stuff you know yeah because
15:30
even if it's just for the accountability
15:32
and once again
15:34
like
15:35
we're super biased because we are
15:36
coaches
15:37
but we also believe in this yeah
15:39
because we know it works
15:41
we're all emotional beings and we often
15:43
make those decisions based on like
15:45
feelings and you know i'm not
15:47
always on logic
15:49
so i think there's something to be said
15:50
about just the accountability side of
15:52
things and right having someone to keep
15:54
you in check
15:56
so i'm not going to lie like i'm in week
15:58
17 of my car it's getting hard now you
16:00
know
16:01
i don't really want to go to the gym
16:03
yeah
16:04
but you have that accountability
16:06
yeah you know and
16:08
macros are pretty low and i'm definitely
16:11
feeling it
16:13
so the accountability
16:14
definitely helps a whole lot
16:16
right
16:17
i also feel like a lot of people are
16:20
expecting the risk of muscle loss to be
16:22
super high right it's like as low as
16:25
soon as we go beyond that one percent
16:26
we're like
16:28
it's probably not going to be too bad
16:30
you know you really have to push it and
16:32
you already have to be very lean
16:34
to really risk quite a bit you know or i
16:37
should say and or so either be super
16:40
lean and or
16:41
really push it in terms of being in a
16:43
deep deficit for too long yeah for too
16:45
long that's the problem deep and too
16:47
long
16:48
yeah so if you don't push it too far you
16:51
should probably be fine and then if you
16:53
keep training as well because i mean i
16:55
know she's going to keep training
16:56
because she loves it
16:58
but
16:59
the amount of training that you need to
17:00
do to hold on to the muscle that you
17:02
have
17:03
is much less
17:05
than what it takes to build it initially
17:08
and i believe it's even you know down to
17:11
a third or less
17:12
right in terms of volume
17:14
so
17:15
in this case
17:17
i wouldn't necessarily worry too much
17:19
about the muscle loss
17:22
you know assuming that sleep is taken
17:23
care of but we'll get into that in a sec
17:26
and then when it comes to training you
17:28
know performance
17:30
yeah you'll see a bit of a drop but
17:31
you'll get that back
17:33
um
17:34
i think the last point here is
17:36
prioritizing sleep
17:39
this is like the foundation to our
17:41
health in general for all things
17:44
so that is
17:48
i would say the most important of them
17:50
all to be honest with you if it's if
17:52
you're asking my opinion
17:54
um that's where all of our repairing is
17:56
happening right that's where we're
17:57
recovering for not getting enough if
17:59
we're not recovering we're going to
18:03
increase the risk of that muscle loss
18:05
plus we're just simply increasing more
18:07
stress on the body
18:09
and again we're trying to
18:11
try to manage that as much as possible
18:13
so sleep is definitely at the top of the
18:16
priority list
18:17
and not just in this case in in every
18:20
case
18:20
whether you have fat loss goals
18:22
performance health
18:25
muscle gain you name it
18:27
yeah it's the cornerstone corner stone
18:30
to our health
18:31
yeah it really is
18:34
because if you sleep like a lot of
18:36
other stuff is always going to suffer
18:38
if you sleep great
18:40
pretty much everything is going to be
18:41
much easier
18:43
decision making you know motivation
18:46
uh actually wanting to train workouts
18:48
make healthy food choices
18:50
sleep is going to affect
18:52
hunger hormones tighter hormones your
18:54
hormones in general like not just those
18:56
you know
18:57
right and then
18:59
and that sleep is even going to affect
19:01
how much muscle you lose compared to how
19:03
much fat you lose so remember we talked
19:06
about fat loss versus weight loss in the
19:08
second episode
19:09
now
19:10
this is exactly what i mean so there's a
19:12
really cool study that compared two
19:14
groups where one group
19:17
was only allowed to spend five and a
19:18
half hours in bed
19:20
the other group
19:21
eight hours
19:24
they compared the data
19:26
and a group who was in bed for five and
19:27
a half hours
19:29
lost way more muscle mass the funny
19:31
thing is that they lost the exact same
19:33
amount of weight
19:35
in terms of kilos
19:37
not in terms of fat loss and muscle
19:39
so even there
19:41
you could have everything dialed in but
19:43
sleep like
19:45
and still risk losing muscle
19:47
so out of all of these and i totally
19:49
agree with you
19:50
out of all of these sleep is probably
19:52
going to be the number one priority
19:55
which should really be the case anyway
19:57
right
19:58
typically athletes are pretty good about
20:00
that though
20:02
i think so because
20:04
and especially in crossfit too because
20:06
we're getting into
20:07
you know apps like romwa to do a little
20:09
bit more of the the stretching and the
20:11
recovery side of things right and we
20:14
tend to be or you know crossfit in
20:16
general tend to be more
20:18
kind of like into it like in into the
20:19
whole thing right not just the
20:21
performance side of things but also
20:22
recovery and just diving a little deeper
20:25
in terms of sleep
20:27
you know nutrition etc
20:29
yeah
20:30
okay let's summarize this and go through
20:33
each point that we touched on
20:35
so the first one was
20:37
not dieting for too long
20:40
and not going
20:42
too aggressive so
20:44
dieting too long and going too
20:45
aggressive we want to
20:47
diet for a shorter amount of time you
20:50
can still go a little bit more
20:52
aggressive here right we just don't want
20:54
that prolonged
20:56
stress on the system
20:59
second thing was to keep protein high so
21:02
we recommend body weight or 1.2 to 1.4
21:06
grams per pound of body weight
21:08
keeping carbohydrates high as well
21:12
and then lastly keep training which i
21:14
know in this case is not going to be an
21:15
issue so you want to keep lifting
21:17
weights you basically want to send a
21:18
signal to your body of hey we still need
21:20
to hold on to these muscles right
21:22
there's still a use for them that's all
21:24
we got to do
21:25
we're not trying to say hey we need to
21:27
build new muscle because it's just not
21:29
the ideal environment for it even though
21:32
sometimes we can still build muscle even
21:34
in the deficit it's just not very likely
21:37
but keep training to send that signal
21:40
and once again it's much easier for your
21:42
body to hold on to the muscle that you
21:44
do have already than to build it
21:47
last point very important for any kind
21:49
of goal any health and fitness goal
21:52
and that is sleeping enough
21:54
ideally when you train a lot i would say
21:56
let's try the aim for
21:59
you know seven eight hours like eight
22:00
would be great but hey let's be
22:02
realistic like that's not always the
22:04
case these days
22:05
um i wouldn't really go lower than seven
22:08
right like
22:10
six
22:11
uh once a week you know
22:14
preferably not at all
22:16
but you know try to emphasize recovery
22:18
because the recovering that you do is
22:20
when you're asleep it's not at the gym
22:23
it's when you're asleep
22:25
you try to aim for 7 to 8 and you should
22:27
be pretty good i'd say
22:30
boom
22:31
those are our tips hope you enjoyed the
22:33
episode and we'll talk to you soon